Burgee Bar - Ocean Reef Club, Key Largo, FL

6 Slices

Great presentation! Smooth pie filling and generous whip cream on top. Side sauce is complementary of the tangy pie. Home style graham crust is thick and holds together well. But it's missing the fresh touch of a perfect pie.

Blue Heaven - Key West, FL

6 Slices

Big props for a monster presentation. A pile of spongy meringue a top a slender slice of KLP. A typical pie and crust with a crown of fluff sets it apart from other locals, but it lacks a certain pizzazz and balanced flavors that kept us from diving in full force.

Catch 53 - Marathon, FL

2 Slices

Decent presentation, but NOT a key lime pie! This fluffy pie tastes more like a lemon meringue pie than something from a fresh key lime. An interesting dessert, but not what we're looking for.

The Breakers - Palm Beach, FL

8 Slices!

Simple, but elegant presentation. Excellent Classic KLP flavor - not to tart. Perfect amount of Key Line flavor. Adding the blackberry compote, or pineapple/orange salsa, enhances the flavors. The distinct flavors are like getting three deserts in one!

Bimini Big Game Club - Bimini, Bahamas

5 Slices

Great presentation and bold key lime flavor, but we were sad to find that it wasn't homemade on the island (didn't taste that way either). Fresh whip cream and garnished with raspberry and chocolate sauce adds in complement.

The Island Tiki Bar - Marathon, FL

6 Slices

Smooth and strong klp flavor with a thin genuine Graham crust, a little sugary though. Beautifully whipped cream with a mild flavor that balances well with the pie. Great classic presentation. (compare with previous post on Sept 1, 2009)

Burdines Chiki Tiki Bar & Grille - Marathon, FL

5 Slices

Smooth filling, but a bit too soft. A nice graham crust with a surprise layer of nuts that adds a special twist to the classic pie that we love! Presentation was lackluster, but we got a fresh lime on top, sans whip cream.

Bonefish Grille - Ft. Lauderdale, FL

6 Slices

Good, thick graham crust. Classic key lime flavor and fresh whip cream. Pie filling was a bit soft, though good tart flavor.

Barracuda Grill - Marathon, FL

3 Slices

Great presentation and portion size, but poor flavor and gooey consistency that leaves much to be desired. (compare with previous post on Aug 26, 2009)

Lazy Days - Marathon, FL

3 Slices

Single portion size with minimal presentation. Very tart filling with mushy, but flavorful, graham crust.

Leigh Ann's Coffee House - Key Colony Beach, FL

4 Slices

Good KL flavor and portion size.  Thick custard filling makes for a heavy dessert instead of refreshing.  Thin, mild crust is good but not a strong enough presence.

The Square Grouper Bar Grill - Cudjoe Key, FL

7 Slices

Great KLP flavor and graham crust.  Balanced proportions of pie and crust.  Velvety smooth and good presentation.
A great rendition of a classic.

Bob's Bunz - Islamorada, FL

5 Slices

Good KLP flavor, a bit creamy in texture an flavor similar to
cheesecake, medium portion, good graham crust.

Frank's Grill - Marathon, FL

5 Slices

Simple, small presentation. Fresh, home made whip cream is amazing.
Texture and temp is a bit frozen, but flavor is mild classic. Typical
graham crust.

Outback Steak House - Islamorada, FL

6 Slices

Nice presentation, complementary gram crumbles. Generous portion size. Light KL flavor and thick gram crust makes for a refreshing dessert.

Island Grill - Islamorada, FL

3 Slices

Refreshing presentation, but fair flavor and typical consistency. Gooey topping is too strong and does not complement the dish.

Islamorada Fish Company - Islamorada, FL

8 Slices

Excellent key lime flavor!
Unique presentation
Personal size
Nice crust texture with cashew nuts
Crumbly crust

Billy's Stone Crab - Tierra Verde, FL

2 Slices

Medium portion
Relatively bland flavor
Poor whip cream topping

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar - Marathon, FL

6 Slices

Good classic key lime flavor and texture. Fresh whip cream melts
instantly, and graham crust is masked and a bit too mushy.

The Hub Baja Grill, Sarasota, FL

5 slices

Great KLP flavor
Great presentation
Soft, whipped texture yet welcomed
Classic Graham crust
Good single portion size
Side sauces are a bit strong