Island Grill - Islamorada, FL

3 Slices

Refreshing presentation, but fair flavor and typical consistency. Gooey topping is too strong and does not complement the dish.

Islamorada Fish Company - Islamorada, FL

8 Slices

Excellent key lime flavor!
Unique presentation
Personal size
Nice crust texture with cashew nuts
Crumbly crust

Billy's Stone Crab - Tierra Verde, FL

2 Slices

Medium portion
Relatively bland flavor
Poor whip cream topping

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar - Marathon, FL

6 Slices

Good classic key lime flavor and texture. Fresh whip cream melts
instantly, and graham crust is masked and a bit too mushy.