Burgee Bar - Ocean Reef Club, Key Largo, FL



6 Slices

Great presentation! Smooth pie filling and generous whip cream on top. Side sauce is complementary of the tangy pie. Home style graham crust is thick and holds together well. But it's missing the fresh touch of a perfect pie.

Blue Heaven - Key West, FL



6 Slices

Big props for a monster presentation. A pile of spongy meringue a top a slender slice of KLP. A typical pie and crust with a crown of fluff sets it apart from other locals, but it lacks a certain pizzazz and balanced flavors that kept us from diving in full force.

Catch 53 - Marathon, FL


2 Slices

Decent presentation, but NOT a key lime pie! This fluffy pie tastes more like a lemon meringue pie than something from a fresh key lime. An interesting dessert, but not what we're looking for.