Barracuda Grill - Marathon, FL

3 Slices

Great presentation and portion size, but poor flavor and gooey consistency that leaves much to be desired. (compare with previous post on Aug 26, 2009)

Lazy Days - Marathon, FL

3 Slices

Single portion size with minimal presentation. Very tart filling with mushy, but flavorful, graham crust.

Leigh Ann's Coffee House - Key Colony Beach, FL

4 Slices

Good KL flavor and portion size.  Thick custard filling makes for a heavy dessert instead of refreshing.  Thin, mild crust is good but not a strong enough presence.

The Square Grouper Bar Grill - Cudjoe Key, FL

7 Slices

Great KLP flavor and graham crust.  Balanced proportions of pie and crust.  Velvety smooth and good presentation.
A great rendition of a classic.

Bob's Bunz - Islamorada, FL

5 Slices

Good KLP flavor, a bit creamy in texture an flavor similar to
cheesecake, medium portion, good graham crust.

Frank's Grill - Marathon, FL

5 Slices

Simple, small presentation. Fresh, home made whip cream is amazing.
Texture and temp is a bit frozen, but flavor is mild classic. Typical
graham crust.

Outback Steak House - Islamorada, FL

6 Slices

Nice presentation, complementary gram crumbles. Generous portion size. Light KL flavor and thick gram crust makes for a refreshing dessert.

Island Grill - Islamorada, FL

3 Slices

Refreshing presentation, but fair flavor and typical consistency. Gooey topping is too strong and does not complement the dish.

Islamorada Fish Company - Islamorada, FL

8 Slices

Excellent key lime flavor!
Unique presentation
Personal size
Nice crust texture with cashew nuts
Crumbly crust

Billy's Stone Crab - Tierra Verde, FL

2 Slices

Medium portion
Relatively bland flavor
Poor whip cream topping

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar - Marathon, FL

6 Slices

Good classic key lime flavor and texture. Fresh whip cream melts
instantly, and graham crust is masked and a bit too mushy.

The Hub Baja Grill, Sarasota, FL

5 slices

Great KLP flavor
Great presentation
Soft, whipped texture yet welcomed
Classic Graham crust
Good single portion size
Side sauces are a bit strong

Cracked Conch Café - Marathon, FL

6 Slices

Basic but appropriate presentation.
Creamy flavor at first then tart mildly kicks in.
Good moderate Graham
cracker crust.
Standard slice size.

Mangrove Mama's - Sugarloaf Key, FL

7 Slices

The classic!
Excellent flavor rich and creamy without too much tart.
Nice graham cracker crust basic but appropriate presentation.

Capellas Italian Resturant - Lincoln Road, Miami, FL

5 Slices

Nice presenstion
Good KL traditional flavor
Small portion
Thin crust

Crab Shack - St. Petersburg, FL

5 Slices

Good mild key lime flavor. Very sugary, especially the crust. Smooth but almost too soft. Normal portion size.

Bahamian Club, Atlantis Resort - Paradise Island, Bahamas

5 Slices

As you can plainly see this "authentic" pie is far from it's aforementioned status...

Great presentation, just not authentic

Poor topping to pie ratio

Good, classic taste

Overall, this was too much. As a bite size "Mini" it would be nicer

Capital Grille - Boca Raton, FL

6 Slices

Strong flavor
Good solid mild Graham crust
Elegant presentation
Pistatios give a new, welcomed twist
Good consistency and texture

Grand Lux Cafe - Boca Raton, FL

6 Slices

Good consistency and flavor, tartness!
Crust is too sugary
Nice appearance and smooth texture
Should use KL instead of lime garnish
Family size portion
Great whip cream

Herbies - Marathon, FL

6 Slices

Classic flavor
Graham cracker crust
Better W/O the wip cream
Moderate size slice

Cheeseburger in Paradise - Fort Myers, FL

6 Slices

Good tart key lime flavor
Dense
Good cool whip topping
Thick crust
Crunchy coconut topping

The Fish House - Key Largo, FL

7 Slices

Nice presentation with the meringue
Excellent flavor
Refreshing
Just enough tartness

Cabana Breezes - Marathon, FL

7 Slices

Beautiful presentation. Creamy texture, buttery graham cracker crust, with a good key lime flavor. Raspberry drizzle adds a nice sweetness to contrast with the tartness of the key lime. Touch of coconut in the pie adds a pleasantly surprising twist.

The Wreck - Grassy Key, FL

6 Slices

Very large creamy cheese cake consistency and portion plenty to share
Thick & buttery graham cracker crust
Good key lime flavor
Presentation basic but good

Stonewood Grill & Tavern - Gainesville, FL

3 Slices

Nice presentation
More lemon than KL flavor
Kiwi sauce and coconut foam
Graham cracker crust good
Overall not an authentic KLP